While I do believe in pursuing some of the healthful benefits on longevity, I also agree with the opening paragraphs (my bold emphasis added)
"Supplements. Peptides. Protein-maxxing. Zone 2 training. Therapeutic plasma exchange. Off-label drugs. Tests, tests and more tests.
The quest to live to 120, or the more modest goal of staying healthy into one’s 80s or 90s, has become a multibillion dollar industry. But as the longevity movement has grown, so has the pushback.
Three books published in the past year capture a growing sentiment that a myopic pursuit of longevity is unrealistic, misguided and potentially harmful. The authors — a doctor, dietitian and scientist — make the case that the industry is capitalizing on people’s insecurities and fears about growing older to sell them products they don’t need, or that don’t work. Here’s what they recommend instead…
Absolutely true.. and part of the reason I started this site, so we can filter out the hype from reality, and focus on the actual research that supports things.
Some of the stuff on here works for some people. I think the differences of opinion are fun and waterfall plots tell us there are real differences too. And they took a shot at Sinclair. Can’t have an article about longevity without mentioning Sinclair.
I agree with the anti-hype strand of the argument even as I would caution that we need to distinguish between fact distorting obsessions and subject matter passion. In any scientific discipline, there is a constant and generally productive tension between the received view and the leading edge. We see some of that in this article. I might also see unscientific subtext in the article insofar as it applies different standards to the science of longevity than I have seen these same people apply to other scientific disciplines. Zeke, of course, has upped his target; it was 70 when he first began saying it. One wonders if he will up it to 80 if and when he reaches a healthy 75.