How to Test Epigenetic Tests

I’ve been pondering the accuracy of currently available epigenetic age tests. I believe the following protocol would be best used to create new and more accurate epigenetic age tests that can truly show an increase in lifespan.

I think the best way to develop an epigenetic age test is to see how well it performs amongst the following 4 cohorts - a control group of mice, a Rapamycin-treated group of mice that had proven extended lifespan, a control group of marmosets, and a Rapamycin-treated group of marmosets that had proven extended lifespan. Then, determine which epigenetic changes are most important between the groups to determine what the epigenetic tests should look for. Since the two Rapamycin-treated groups have proven extended lifespan, it should lead to clues as to which epigenetic factors are most important for lifespan extension.

Steve Horvath, the founding father of epigenetic age tests, did test the Rapamycin-treated marmosets using the currently available epigenetic age tests and found that there was no difference in epigenetic age results between the two groups of marmosets. This tells us that the current set of epigenetic age tests are testing the wrong biomarkers if we want to measure the effectiveness of lifespan extending treatments such as Rapamycin!

4 Likes

Matt on epigenetic age tests.

3 Likes

What if the 3 legs of the mature ageing stool (mitochondrial decline, epigenetic drift, and senescent cell burden) are much too independent from each other to be tracked via these epigenetic assessments. I believe there’s a case to be made that the legs are tangentially connected ex. Mitochondrial decline can lead to epigenetic methylation patterns in a “old way” or conversely, robust and healthy mitochondria can lead to a decreased senescent cell burden.

The chromatin can be observed for Rapamycin effects and chromatin and its size and organization is considered an epigenetic factor.

1 Like

Yes, Matt and Dr. Attia mutually agree “that they do not work”

1 Like