5 is scary. I take a lot of anti oxidants herbs like high gingerol ginger and Ceylon cinnamon daily, except on strength training days (once a week - body by science).
Yes. The half lives of skeletal muscle components are in the weeks to months range. Any extra muscle you build in youth or middle age will have turned over several times before you’re old, just like how any extra oxygen you breath is gone 10 minutes later.
Unless I missed something, the only reference he gives that might support high protein diets for longevity of healthy young or middle age adults is Naghshi et al.. The others are either about the elderly, or about building muscle without respect to longevity. My concerns are that the effect Naghshi found may be:
- driven entirely by sick, frail, or old individuals, for whom extra protein would be useful
- confounded by characteristics of the diet varying along with protein intake – for example total energy intake, fiber, or simple sugars
- confounded by some obscure mix of behavioral factors, as is common in nutritional epidemiology
It would take some work to dig through all the component studies to see if these concerns are warranted. I con’t have time to do more than look at a few of the higher weighted ones, so any additional comment in that direction would be appreciated.
As a one-size-fits-all recommendation across the (often sedentary or unhealthy) population, modifying diet build muscle makes a fair bit of sense. But is that the best course for a hypothetical, already strong, 35 year old? Me? You?
1 Like
Not interested in long argument. The evidence says if you want to live long, you have to be healthy as an elder person. That requires avoiding frailty. Its much easier to keep muscle rather than add it on when you’re 70.
Stanfield, Attia, Kaeberlein, etc all agree.
4 Likes
Fracture risk and cognition are also important.
It quickly goes downhill for muscle mass/strength once someone breaks a bone or has a fracture that makes them less mobile. Decrease in cognition might lead to poorer diet and decision making leading to said injuries, etc.
How to have strong bones is very important as well.
4 Likes
I’ve gone back and forth several times over the past two years on whether or not to pay attention to Brad Stanfield (i.e., stay subscribed to his channel). He has a habit of not making his underlying assumptions explicit and occasionally uses poor logic to draw conclusions. Whenever I’ve spotted these things in his videos, I have asked him (in the comments) to please clarify, but I have never received any response. I finally decided to unsubscribe for good a month or so ago.
1 Like
He is what I call a hybrid. Somewhere between a brainwashed doctor and one that dabbles from time to time into reality. So, I watch his vids but i only take the points that make sense. For example, he is right when he says we need protein to maintain health as we age. I agree, give me that thick 14 OZ organic steak please loaded with butter and wine sauce lol. But I agree some of what he said the logic to support his position is poor at best. He is also right about resveratrol being harmful.
All in all, I do like to have a contra voice (against the crazies such as Sinclair), but I’ll believe what suits me, not what he wants me to believe lol.
1 Like