Two studies: Bezafibrate induces Liver autophagy

I took Bezafibrate for several months before I started on Rapamycin. Four years ago, it cost something like $0.35 a tablet in Mexico.
This medication is not FDA registered. I can see trump’s wall from my yard and I plan to walk across the border soon and buy some.

Animal and human cell study:

“Bezafibrate induces autophagy and improves hepatic lipid metabolism in glycogen storage disease type Ia”

Here, we observed that bezafibrate increased phosphorylation of AMPK and autophagy (Fig. 2) but did not suppress mTOR activity (Supplementary Material, Fig. S2)
https://academic.oup.com/hmg/article/28/1/143/5106899?login=false

Human Study:

“Bezafibrate for an Inborn Mitochondrial Beta-Oxidation Defect”
Before treatment, the palmistry L-carnitine oxidation levels were markedly reduced (by 21 to 54% of the normal value), reductions that were consistent with CPT2 deficiency. After bezafibrate treatment, the values increased significantly in the six patients (by 60 to 284%, P=0.03) (Figure 1A). In addition, CPT2 messenger RNA in skeletal muscle increased in all the patients (by 20 to 93%, P=0.002) (Figure 1B), as did the CPT2 protein level (data not shown), findings that were consistent with the increased oxidation levels.
https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc0806334?referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fduckduckgo.com%2F

I ran this through my Claude Opus 5.5. summarizer:

Old Lipid Pill Restarts the Liver’s Recycling System in a Rare Sugar-Storage Disease

Researchers at Duke and Duke-NUS gave bezafibrate, a decades-old triglyceride-lowering drug, to newborn mice and adult dogs with glycogen storage disease type Ia (GSD Ia). In mice, five days of treatment cut liver fat by about half, shifted autophagy markers toward normal, raised mitochondrial DNA and switched liver enzymes from fat-making to fat-burning. In three dogs, a liver damage marker fell by about 40 percent and one liver mass disappeared on ultrasound. Glycogen was not reliably reduced, the mice still died young, groups were tiny, and the dogs had no control group.

A cheap lipid-lowering drug prescribed in Europe and Japan for decades may be able to restart a stalled cleanup system in the liver, according to work in mice and dogs with a rare inherited disorder.

The disorder is glycogen storage disease type Ia, or von Gierke’s disease. People born with it lack a working copy of glucose-6-phosphatase, the enzyme the liver uses for the final step of releasing sugar into the blood. The sugar gets trapped. Blood glucose crashes between meals, and the liver swells with stored glycogen and fat. Patients survive by eating uncooked cornstarch on a strict timetable, but the diet does not fix the liver. Among patients older than 25, 70 to 80 percent have at least one liver adenoma, a benign tumour that can turn cancerous.

Dwight Koeberl at Duke University and Paul Yen at Duke-NUS in Singapore had shown earlier that livers in this disease stop performing autophagy, the process cells use to break down and recycle their own contents, including fat droplets. Rapamycin restored it in mice, but rapamycin can disturb blood sugar and cause other side effects, a poor fit for children with a glucose disorder. So the team tried bezafibrate, which activates PPAR receptors, the sensors that tell the liver to behave as if it is fasting.

Newborn mice lacking the enzyme received daily injections for five days. Liver fat fell by a little more than half. Protein markers of autophagy moved toward recovery, and electron microscope images showed fat and glycogen inside the cell’s recycling compartments. Mitochondrial DNA rose by about 70 percent, and swollen, misshapen mitochondria looked closer to normal. A key fat-making enzyme dropped back to healthy levels while fat-burning enzymes rose. Unlike rapamycin, the drug did this without changing mTOR activity. AMPK, the cell’s low-fuel sensor, appeared to be the route instead.

In three adult dogs with the same disease, kept alive by gene therapy, a few months of oral bezafibrate lowered a blood marker of liver damage by about 40 percent and lengthened the time the animals could fast. In one dog, a liver mass seen on ultrasound shrank and then could no longer be found.

The caveats are heavy. Each mouse group contained three to six animals. Glycogen, the defining feature of the disease, did not fall significantly at five days and was not lower at all after ten. The mice still died young, and the ten-day treated animals had larger livers relative to body weight. The dog experiment had no untreated comparison group, and the vanished mass was never biopsied. The senior authors hold a financial interest in the approach, and the drug was supplied by a company that also funded the work.

The authors suggest the findings could matter for ordinary fatty liver disease. That is a hypothesis. Human trials of fibrates in common fatty liver have lowered blood fats without clearly clearing fat from the liver, so the gap between a newborn knockout mouse and an adult clinic remains wide.

Actionable Insights

For almost all readers there is nothing here to act on directly. This is a short experiment in newborn mice with a lethal genetic disease, plus three dogs. It does not show that bezafibrate helps healthy livers, slows ageing or extends life.

What it does show, in size:

  • Five days of treatment cut liver fat by about 56 percent in diseased mice (roughly 1,230 down to 540 mg/dL). That is still about six times the healthy level.
  • In the dogs, the liver enzyme ALT fell about 42 percent (roughly 325 to 190 U/L), which is still above normal.
  • With three or four animals per group, the true effect could easily be half or double these figures.

One finding cuts the other way. In healthy mouse pups, bezafibrate roughly doubled liver fat (not statistically significant). A drug that corrects a disease state may do nothing useful in a normal one.

Practical points:

  • Families dealing with GSD Ia can raise fibrates with their metabolic specialist. These drugs are already used for the high triglycerides the disease causes.
  • Bezafibrate is not approved in the United States. Fenofibrate is the nearest equivalent.
  • Fibrates carry real risks: muscle injury (especially alongside statins), kidney effects and gallstones. This paper is no basis for taking one “for autophagy”.

Biomarker Data (Effect Size Calculation)

How to read this: Cohen’s d is the gap between two groups measured in units of their natural scatter. A d of 0.8 is conventionally “large”. Values of 3 to 5 look spectacular, but with three or four animals per group they are inflated and imprecise. The 95 percent confidence interval shows the plausible range; when it nearly touches zero, the effect is not secure.

Mice, 5 days of treatment (knockout + vehicle n = 3 vs knockout + bezafibrate n = 4):

Outcome Vehicle Bezafibrate Change Cohen’s d (95% CI) Paper’s test
Liver triglyceride (mg/dL) 1,230 540 -56% (-690) -3.5 (-5.9 to -1.1) ANOVA, P < 0.001
Liver glycogen (umol glucose/mg protein) 0.92 0.49 -47% (-0.43) -1.8 (-3.6 to 0.0) Not significant
Mitochondrial DNA (fold) 0.55 0.95 +73% 4.8 (1.9 to 7.7) P < 0.01
LC3-II protein 0.9 1.9 about +110% 3.2 (0.9 to 5.4) ANOVA
p62 protein 2.15 1.5 -30% -2.2 (-4.1 to -0.3) ANOVA
p-AMPK / AMPK 0.30 0.55 +83% 3.3 (1.0 to 5.6) t-test only
PGC-1 alpha protein 0.60 0.75 +25% 2.0 (0.2 to 3.8) t-test only, P = 0.03
Fatty acid synthase protein 1.65 0.65 -61% -5.0 (-8.0 to -2.0) ANOVA

Context for these numbers:

  • Healthy liver triglyceride was about 90 mg/dL, so treatment removed about 60 percent of the excess fat and left the liver far from normal.
  • PPAR-alpha protein rose about 4-fold (t-test, P = 0.04) with no change in its mRNA.
  • Plasma triglycerides, free fatty acids, body weight, liver weight and blood glucose did not change at 5 days.

Mice, 10 days of treatment (n = 6 per knockout group):

Outcome Vehicle Bezafibrate Change Cohen’s d (95% CI)
Liver triglyceride (mg/dL) 500 130 -74% (-370) -1.1 (-2.3 to 0.1)
Plasma triglyceride (mg/dL) 6,900 1,100 -84% (-5,800) -1.3 (-2.5 to 0.0)
Liver glycogen 1.28 1.43 +12% 0.2 (-0.9 to 1.4)
Acadm (MCAD) mRNA 1.5 2.85 +90% 1.8 (0.5 to 3.1)
Blood glucose (mg/dL) below 20 (meter floor) about 68 not calculable not valid

Context for these numbers:

  • The triglyceride drops look larger in percent terms than at 5 days but are statistically weaker, because the vehicle group varied enormously (standard deviation close to the mean).
  • Blood glucose became measurable but reached only about a quarter of the healthy level (about 300 mg/dL). A standardised effect size is meaningless when one group sits on the meter’s floor.
  • Liver weight relative to body weight increased significantly with treatment.

Dogs (n = 3, baseline vs 2.4 months, no control):

  • ALT: about 325 to 190 U/L, a 42 percent fall (135 U/L). Significant only by one-tailed paired t-test, and still above the normal range.
  • Fasting glucose curve (8-hour AUC): about 365 to 520, a 42 percent rise, with no statistical test reported.
  • Liver mass in one dog: 1.68 x 1.62 cm to 1.47 x 0.85 cm at 1.2 months (about 54 percent smaller in cross-section), then undetectable at 3.6 months.
  • Serum triglycerides and cholesterol: fell, not significant.

Evaluating the Claims:

Claim: Activating PPAR-alpha switches on liver autophagy.

  • Evidence level: D. Flag: preclinical only.
  • Finding: PPAR-alpha and FXR compete for the same sites on autophagy gene promoters, and fasting-activated PPAR-alpha reverses autophagy suppression. Nutrient-sensing nuclear receptors coordinate autophagy (2014)
  • Verdict: Strong basic science in a top journal. No human evidence located. Translational Gap.

Claim: GSD Ia livers have defective mitochondria, and bezafibrate restores mitochondrial biogenesis.

Claim: Bezafibrate works through AMPK activation without inhibiting mTOR.

  • Evidence level: D, single study, borderline statistics.
  • Finding: Source unverified in live search. I found no independent replication of bezafibrate-driven AMPK activation in liver.
  • Verdict: Unconfirmed.

Claim: Dose and safety context (mouse 12 mg/kg injected, dog 4 mg/kg oral, human 400 mg daily).

  • Evidence level: A for the creatinine effect; reference-grade for the rest.
  • Finding: Fibrates roughly double the rate of creatinine rises (relative risk 1.99) in the Lancet meta-analysis above. A drug reference confirms the 400 mg daily dose, the muscle, kidney and gallstone warnings, the statin caution, and that bezafibrate is not FDA-approved or marketed in the US. Bezafibrate drug monograph, MedicineNet
  • Verdict: Supported.