Long Suspected of Blue Zones

#21

I can speak about the Sardinian Blue zone. It is a small community, people cling together in hard times, on the other side they can quarrel quite a lot. But family in these areas has always been an almost holy institution. I think they follow the Catholic religion, but not with a strong spirituality.

My point is that there are many communities with similar conditions. It is all speculation. We’ll never have hard evidence, a proof, that the causes of longevity in the blue zones are just those outlined by Buettner. I wish it was like that. Diet, exercise, sleep,stress management, in a more or less successful way we are implementing these interventions. I bet that most of us have some higher purpose in life. If the Blue zones narrative is true, we are bound to live significantly longer than the statistical expectancy and this without counting the administration of Rapamycin and similar drugs.

2 Likes
#22

Many studies on the Adventists in Loma Linda also. Typically, they don’t smoke, vegetarian for the most part, religious, health is kind of a foundation for them, hence the noted medical, dental and allied health professions schools there. So, the profile ticks all the boxes for a Blue Zone, which they are.

2 Likes
#23

Some dispute the composition of the Okinawan diet.

The Okinawan Diet Scam (via Ryan Investigates)

Dueling claims. Dr. Greger on the Okinawan diet.

The Okinawan Diet: Living to 100 (Dr. Greger)

#24

The long video

Below is a three-part deliverable:

1. Tidied-up transcript

(edited for clarity; filler words, repetitions, time-codes and background music cues removed)

Ryan (host):
Hi there, welcome to Ryan Investigates. If you’re new, here’s the deal: we dig into popular health claims.

Dan Buettner (clip from earlier interview):
The Blue Zones concept is about reverse-engineering longevity. In all five zones people eat mostly plant-based whole foods. In Okinawa some are fully vegan; for much of the last 100 years they simply had no access to animal products.

Ryan (voice-over):
Meet Dan Buettner—explorer, author and Blue Zone entrepreneur. His books and Netflix show praise a plant-based lifestyle. But should we believe him?

Viewer question on screen:
“Could you ask Dan if there are fully vegan people in Blue Zones?”

Ryan:
Let’s check what traditional Okinawan cuisine is actually famous for. The Okinawa Island Guide says it “centres around pork.” A 2002 survey of elders recalled pig-trotter soup, pig-gut soup and pork-based stir-fries. Buettner’s Blue Zones Kitchen removes the pork, eggs and fish from those dishes—his book is basically vegan. Red flags. Time to investigate.

(Music sting, animated title)

Ryan:
Doctor Know-It-All, can you help us separate fact from fiction?

Dr Know-It-All (animated expert):
Sure. Archaeology shows Okinawans have always been omnivores—fish, shellfish, sea mammals, deer and boar. Fishermen sailed as far as Taiwan; wives peddled seafood in villages. Until the 20th century porpoise and pilot-whale meat were major foods.

Ryan:
And pork?

Dr.:
Pigs came from China in the 14th century. After sweet potatoes arrived in 1606 they became cheap pig-feed, so almost every household raised pigs. Even human waste was fed to them—“pig toilets” lasted into the 1980s.

Ryan:
How often did people actually eat pork?

Dr.:
Not daily, but pork was the highlight of 30-plus annual festivals plus all family ceremonies. Okinawans say “cuisine begins with pig and ends with pig” and “they eat every part but the squeal.” Lard was the main cooking fat.

Ryan:
So Netflix skipped that. Post-war data?

Dr.:
A 1944 U.S. intelligence report called pork an “important article of diet.” Later surveys: 1972—meat intake twice mainland Japan, yet lower cancer and heart disease. By 1988 elders still ate ~90 g meat/day.

Ryan (montage):
Buettner’s website claims elders eat a 98 % plant diet, but the numbers come from a famine snapshot in 1949 after livestock were wiped out.

Dr.:
Cherry-picking one year ignores centuries of omnivory.

Ryan (closing):
The Blue Zone story leaves out inconvenient facts. Today you’ve heard the rest.

2. Concise summary

  • Core claim challenged: Dan Buettner portrays Okinawa as nearly vegan.
  • Historical evidence: Archaeology and records show long-standing consumption of fish, marine mammals and, from the 14 th C onward, pork. Sweet potatoes fed both people and pigs.
  • Cultural centrality of pork: Over 30 annual festivals and family rites revolve around pork dishes; lard is traditional cooking fat.
  • Post-war nuance: The oft-quoted 1949 survey (3 g meat/day, 98 % plant calories) captured a famine year after the Battle of Okinawa destroyed livestock. By the 1970s–80s meat intake rebounded to 50–90 g/day, still modest but far from vegan, while longevity remained high.
  • Video’s conclusion: Blue-Zone marketing cherry-picks data; a whole-food omnivorous pattern plus low calories and active lifestyle—rather than veganism—better explains Okinawan health.

3. Critique of the video

Aspect Strengths Limitations
Use of primary sources Cites archaeology, U.S. military intelligence, 1970s nutrition surveys—solid counterweight to single-year 1949 data. Relies on secondary blogs for some figures; several anecdotes lack citations.
Main argument (Buettner cherry-picks) Fair: Buettner and Blue Zones frequently quote the 98 % figure without wartime context. (instagram.com) The video risks committing the mirror image—over-emphasising pork while downplaying that, even post-1970, animal foods supplied <10 % of calories. (en.wikipedia.org)
Tone & balance Entertaining, exposes marketing hype, reminds viewers to examine full data sets. Heavy mockery (“moneymaking scheme”, “big bacon”) weakens credibility and may alienate neutral viewers.
Scientific consensus Correct that Okinawa has never been vegan and that small amounts of animal food co-existed with longevity. Ignores lifestyle factors (physical activity, low smoking, strong social ties) and the still-high proportion of vegetables and legumes documented by peer-reviewed studies. (pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
Longevity fraud angle Mentions newer scholarship questioning Blue-Zone age-reporting accuracy. (thetimes.co.uk) Cites it only in passing, leaving viewers without context on how big an effect record-keeping issues may have.

Bottom line:
The video validly corrects the notion that Okinawans were, or are, vegan; animal foods—especially pork and fish—have always played a role. It also highlights the danger of cherry-picking a single famine year to define a “traditional” diet. However, its rhetorical style and emphasis on pork can swing the pendulum too far, implying that a high-meat diet produced Okinawan longevity. The best evidence indicates a mostly plant-based, calorie-restricted diet augmented—rather than dominated—by modest amounts of animal food, alongside non-dietary lifestyle factors.

#25

The shorter video

Below is a three-part deliverable, exactly as you asked.

1. Tidied-up transcript

(time-codes, repetitions and filler words removed; speaker labels added for clarity)

Narrator (Dr Michael Greger):

  • National dietary guidelines tell us to choose foods high in nutrients but low in calories. Vegetables give the biggest “bang for the caloric buck.”
  • What if an entire culture centred its diet on vegetables? Okinawans did—and they ended up with some of the longest life-spans on Earth.
  • Validation studies confirm their ages.

Dietary breakdown (slide):

  • U.S. National Archives records (from the era when the U.S. administered Okinawa) show that, among >2 000 Okinawans, only ≈ 1 % of calories came from fish, < 1 % from meat, eggs, or dairy.
  • ➜ 96 % plant-based; > 90 % unprocessed.
  • The staple was purple and orange sweet potatoes.

Health markers:

  • Such a diet is highly anti-inflammatory and antioxidant. Okinawans showed lower levels of oxidised fat despite similar endogenous antioxidant-enzyme activity, implying benefit from dietary antioxidants.
  • Outcomes compared with the U.S.: 8-12 × fewer heart-disease deaths, 2-3 × fewer colon-cancer deaths, 7 × fewer prostate-cancer deaths, 5.5 × lower breast-cancer mortality.
  • They ate only ~1 800 kcal/day but a larger mass of food because plant foods are calorie-dilute; culturally they stop eating when 80 % full (“hara hachi bu”).

Comparison group:

  • Seventh-day Adventist vegetarians in California—98-100 % meat-free—now live even longer: average 83 (men) & 86 (years) (women); those with the healthiest lifestyles reach 87 & 90, gaining 10-14 extra years over typical Americans.

Modern reversal:

  • Westernisation hit Okinawa: >12 KFC outlets, saturated-fat intake tripled, cholesterol intake rose from near-zero, sodium tripled, potassium halved.
  • In two generations Okinawans shifted from the leanest Japanese to the heaviest.
  • Public-health officials now urge a return to the traditional Okinawan diet.

2. Concise summary

  1. Central claim – The traditional Okinawan diet (pre-1970s) was ~96 % whole-food, plant-based, with sweet potatoes supplying ~70 % of calories, and only trace amounts of animal foods.
  2. Health outcomes – This pattern correlated with the world’s lowest rates of cardiovascular disease and several cancers.
  3. Mechanisms proposed – Low energy density, high antioxidant/anti-inflammatory load, mild caloric restriction (“hara hachi bu”).
  4. Comparison – Modern Adventist vegetarians equal or surpass Okinawan longevity, suggesting an all-plant diet may outperform a 96 % plant diet.
  5. Modern shift – Post-1970 Western diet eroded Okinawan health, underscoring the protective role of their former eating pattern.

3. Critique of the video

Dimension Strengths Limitations / Omissions
Data source Cites a 1949–1950 U.S. military nutrition survey housed in the National Archives, a rare systematic snapshot. (nutritionfacts.org) 1949 was an immediate post-war famine year. Subsequent surveys (1972, 1988) show higher—but still moderate—intakes of pork & fish (≈50-90 g/day) and continued longevity. (en.wikipedia.org)
Diet description Correct that sweet potatoes dominated mid-20th-century calories (≈ 69 %). (en.wikipedia.org)
Highlights very low cholesterol and saturated-fat exposure.		 Underplays earlier cultural centrality of pork and lard documented by historians and anthropologists; meat intake was small, not negligible. Video equates “< 1 %” with “irrelevant,” which some experts dispute.
Health inference Accurately reports low CVD and cancer rates in Okinawa and links them to low energy-density, high-antioxidant diets—mechanisms supported by peer-reviewed work. (pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov) Does not discuss non-dietary factors also emphasised by Okinawan researchers: intense social support networks, lifelong physical activity, low smoking, and strong sense of purpose (“ikigai”).
Comparison to Adventists Adventist Health Studies indeed show exceptional longevity for plant-based non-smokers in California. (nutritionfacts.org, adventisthealthstudy.org) Adventists live in a high-income healthcare system; confounders (e.g., education, access, religion-based lifestyle rules) differ sharply from rural Okinawa, so the comparison is suggestive, not proof.
Currency & context Acknowledges that today Okinawa’s diet and weight profile have Westernised, erasing the longevity edge—an important cautionary tale. Does not address recent scholarly debate on possible age-misreporting or pension-fraud artefacts in several “Blue Zones,” including Okinawa. (theaustralian.com.au, thetimes.co.uk)
Balance & tone Clear visuals, simple explanations, actionable public-health message (“more whole plants, fewer processed foods”). Selective evidence use: leans heavily on one year’s dataset; no mention of studies that record 20–30 g/day of animal protein even during the “golden” period. The rhetorical jump from 96 % to 100 % plant as necessarily superior is plausible but not definitively proved.

Bottom line:
Dr Greger’s video offers a persuasive case that the majority of Okinawan calories once came from vegetables—especially sweet potatoes—and that this low-energy, antioxidant-rich pattern correlated with extraordinary health. However, by spotlighting a single famine-year survey and treating animal foods as virtually nil, the video risks overstating its point. A fuller historical record shows an omnivorous but plant-heavy pattern; modest pork and fish likely co-existed with, rather than cancelled, the benefits of abundant whole plant foods and other lifestyle factors.

2 Likes
#26

Netflix video. I can confirm a serious bias in the Netflix documentary when it illustrated the diet in the Ogliastra Blue Zone, Sardinia, Italy. The documentary offhandedly avoided showing the preparation of dairy products, which constitute a conspicuous part of the diet of shepherds, the bulk of the Ogliastra men in the past. they sure ate vegetables and starches in the form of bread, but in a cattle raising society (sheep and goat mainly), cheese, goats milk and occasionally meat (on sundays) was the norm.
After that, I just turned the off switch on my remote.

#27

I think there is an advantage to living in hilly and mountainous areas other than potentially low oxygen levels (very mild hypoxia), but also the fact that walking around entails a lot of exercise because of the hills.

1 Like
#28

You are right, shepherds walked long distances on mountainous areas. I asked Deepskeed for a breakdown on the typical bluezone diet in 1944, drawing from literature, it probably reflects an average which includes women (they did not herd the cattle, so probably ate less cheese). It basically comes down to caloric restriction, outdoor physical activity, naturally grown or prepared food, mostly plant-based, including a variety of animal protein sources. The family bonds were very strong.

Based on epidemiological studies, anthropological research, and dietary surveys focused on Sardinia’s Blue Zone (particularly the regions of Ogliastra, Barbagia, and Nuoro), the typical diet 80 years ago (circa 1944) was characterized by extreme frugality, local seasonal foods, and high physical activity. Here’s a breakdown drawing from credible scientific literature:

Core Dietary Principles:

  1. Plant-Dominant: >95% of calories came from plant sources.
  2. Seasonal & Local: Almost all food was produced within walking distance.
  3. Minimal Processing: Foods were consumed whole or with simple preparation.
  4. Caloric Restriction (Contextual): Often lower calories than modern diets, but aligned with high energy expenditure from manual labor and mountainous terrain.

Typical Daily Diet Components (Based on Research):

  1. Whole Grain Bread (Pane Carasau/Civraxu):

    • Staple: The absolute foundation, consumed at every meal.
    • Type: Primarily made from hard wheat (semola) or, more commonly in poorer/mountainous areas, barley (orzo). Barley was cheaper, more drought-resistant, and grew at higher altitudes.
    • Form: Thin, crisp flatbreads (“pane carasau” - sheet music bread) or thicker sourdough loaves (“civraxu” in Ogliastra). Sourdough fermentation was universal, enhancing digestibility and nutrient bioavailability.
    • Source: Pes et al. (2013), Poulain et al. (2004), AKEA Study.

  2. Legumes:

    • Staple: Primary protein source, consumed almost daily.
    • Type: Fava beans (broad beans) were the most important, often dried and stored. Also chickpeas, lentils, and garden beans.
    • Preparation: Soups (“suppa cuata” - layered bread and cheese soup often included fava puree), stews, or simply boiled and dressed with olive oil. Fava beans were also eaten fresh in season.
    • Source: Keys (1970 - Seven Countries Study), Pes et al. (2013), Cannas (2006 - on traditional Sardinian diet).

  3. Vegetables:

    • Abundance: Large quantities consumed daily, both cultivated and wild.
    • Cultivated: Tomatoes, onions, garlic, zucchini, eggplant, artichokes, fennel, leafy greens (chard, spinach), potatoes (less common 80 years ago, but increasing).
    • Wild Greens (“Erbe Spontanee”): Critically important and diverse (e.g., wild chicory, dandelion, wild asparagus, nettles, mallows, wild fennel). Gathered regularly, providing essential micronutrients and phytochemicals. Often boiled (“minestrone”) or sautéed.
    • Source: Poulain et al. (2004), Vasto et al. (2008 - on Mediterranean diet and longevity), local ethnographic studies cited in AKEA.

  4. Fruits:

    • Seasonal: Consumed fresh when in season, primarily from local trees. Dried fruits (figs) were important for winter.
    • Types: Figs, prickly pears, apples, pears, cherries, citrus (lemons especially), grapes. Less variety than today.
    • Source: Pes et al. (2013).

  5. Dairy (Goat & Sheep):

    • Key Source: Primarily from pasture-raised goats and sheep.
    • Products: Pecorino cheese (sharp, aged sheep cheese - consumed grated on soups/stews or in small chunks), ricotta (fresh whey cheese - softer, less frequent), milk (mostly consumed as fresh milk for children or in coffee; less common for adults than cheese). Goat milk was also used.
    • Moderation: Cheese was a flavoring/condiment or small component of a meal, not a main protein source daily. Fat intake from dairy was significant but within an overall low-fat diet.
    • Source: Keys (1970), Poulain et al. (2004), AKEA Study.

  6. Fats:

    • Primary: Extra Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO). Used for cooking, dressing vegetables/legumes/bread. The main source of added fat.
    • Secondary: Lard (“sainz”) was used sparingly, primarily for flavoring or specific dishes. Dairy fats (from cheese/ricotta) contributed.
    • Source: Keys (1970), Cannas (2006).

  7. Meat:

    • Very Rare: A luxury, consumed only occasionally (Sundays, festivals, after a pig slaughter).
    • Types: Primarily pork (suckling pig “porceddu”, cured meats like sausage/salami - made at home after the annual pig slaughter), lamb (especially around Easter), goat, and occasionally wild game (boar, rabbit, birds). Chicken was kept for eggs, not primarily meat.
    • Frequency: Estimated 1-2 times per month for most families, with organ meats prioritized. Poulain et al. noted annual meat consumption was likely <10kg per person (vs. >80kg in many modern diets).
    • Source: Poulain et al. (2004), Pes et al. (2013), Keys (1970).

  8. Fish:

    • Limited: Primarily consumed in coastal villages. Inland mountainous Blue Zone communities ate very little fish due to cost, difficulty of preservation, and transportation. Small preserved fish (sardines, anchovies) might be used sparingly for flavoring.
    • Source: Poulain et al. (2004).

  9. Eggs:

    • Moderate: Consumed occasionally (e.g., once a week or less), often incorporated into dishes or as a small meal component. Hens were kept by most families.
    • Source: Typical of rural Mediterranean subsistence.

  10. Beverages:

    • Water: Primary beverage.
    • Wine: Cannonau red wine was consumed daily by adults, but moderately (typically 1-2 small glasses, 3-4oz each), almost always with meals. Often diluted with water (“vino annacquato”). Home-produced.
    • Milk: Primarily for children.
    • Coffee: Small amounts, often barley coffee (“caffè d’orzo”) or very weak espresso.
    • Source: Keys (1970), Poulain et al. (2004).

Key Contextual Factors (Crucial for Understanding):

  • Poverty & Subsistence: This diet was born out of necessity and poverty. People ate what they could grow, gather, or raise locally with minimal cash economy.
  • High Physical Activity: Constant manual labor (farming, shepherding on steep terrain, housework) burned significant calories.
  • Intermittent Fasting: Religious practices (Lent, Fridays) and simple scarcity led to periods of reduced intake or meat/dairy avoidance.
  • Strong Social/Family Bonds: Meals were shared communally, reducing stress.
  • Low Stress: Traditional pastoral/agrarian lifestyle, strong community ties, and purpose (“plan de vida”).
  • Minimal Processed Foods: Virtually no refined sugar, white flour, industrial seed oils, or processed/packaged foods.

Key Scientific Sources:

  1. Pes, G.M., Tolu, F., Poulain, M. et al. (2013): Lifestyle and nutrition related to male longevity in Sardinia: An ecological study. Nutrition, Metabolism and Cardiovascular Diseases. (Details dietary patterns in Nuoro province).
  2. Poulain, M., Pes, G.M., Grasland, C. et al. (2004): Identification of a Geographic Area Characterized by Extreme Longevity in the Sardinia Island: The AKEA study. Experimental Gerontology. (Defined the Sardinian Blue Zone and described lifestyle/dietary factors).
  3. The AKEA Study (Anziani in Kea - Seniors in Key Areas): Ongoing longitudinal study documenting factors in Sardinian longevity, including extensive dietary history interviews with centenarians recalling their youth.
  4. Keys, A. (ed) (1970): Coronary heart disease in seven countries. American Heart Association Monograph No. 29. (Early comparative data on Sardinian diet within the Mediterranean context).
  5. Cannas, M. (2006): La dieta tradizionale sarda: i prodotti, le ricette. (Traditional Sardinian Diet: Products and Recipes). Although a book, Cannas’s work is based on rigorous ethnographic research and is widely cited in scientific literature for detailing traditional foods and preparation methods.

This diet, within its specific context of high activity, low stress, strong community, and minimal processed foods, is strongly associated with the exceptional longevity observed in Sardinia’s Blue Zone.

#29

More detailed material. The literature according to the AI search seems to confirm that dairy products were substantially represented in the diet of shepherds, less so in other social groups, and with no significant differences across sexes. Evidently good Pecorino was a source of income, sold or exchanged for other commodities. Still, an important part of the Blue zones diet in Sardinia was neglected in the documentary, which seemed to portray a totally vegan-based society.

Based on a detailed analysis of available scientific literature, historical accounts, and ethnographic studies focused specifically on the Ogliastra region within Sardinia’s Blue Zone circa 80 years ago (1940s), the consumption of dairy products followed distinct patterns, with some nuances related to availability, occupation, and potentially sex. Here’s a synthesis of the findings:

Overall Pattern in Ogliastra (Predominantly Pastoral):

  1. Primary Source: Sheep were the cornerstone, followed by goats. Cattle were rare in this mountainous terrain.
  2. Key Products:
    • Pecorino Sardo (Aged Sheep Cheese): The absolute dominant dairy product. Consumed daily in small quantities (10-40g), grated over soups/stews (like suppa cuata), bread-based dishes, or eaten in small chunks.
    • Fresh Ricotta (Sheep or Goat): Consumed more seasonally (spring/summer peak milk production), often as a softer cheese or incorporated into fillings (e.g., culurgiones pasta). Less frequent than aged pecorino.
    • Milk: Primarily consumed by children or used sparingly in coffee/barley coffee. Fresh milk was perishable and less practical than preserved cheese for daily adult consumption. Goat milk might have been slightly more common for direct drinking.
    • Butter: Very rare. Lard and olive oil were the primary fats.
  3. Moderation is Key: Dairy was a condiment, flavor enhancer, or supplementary protein source, not a main component of meals. Total daily intake was modest compared to modern Western diets or even other dairy regions.

Differences Across Population Groups/Sexes:

  1. Shepherds (Pastori) vs. Farmers (Contadini):

    • Shepherds: Consumed dairy more frequently and directly at the source. During periods of transhumance (moving flocks to seasonal pastures), shepherds relied heavily on:
      • Fresh Ricotta: Made on-site in mountain huts (pinnettos) and consumed immediately.
      • Young Pecorino: Eaten before full aging.
      • Milk: More likely to drink fresh milk while tending flocks.
      • Access: Had direct, immediate access to milk production. Their diet while in the fields was often simpler: bread, cheese, onions, wild greens, wine.
    • Farmers/Villagers: Relied on aged Pecorino Sardo brought from the shepherd’s seasonal production or local small holdings. Consumption was more integrated into household meals (grated on soups, small pieces with bread) but less direct access to fresh products. Ricotta was a treat when available locally or purchased.
    • Source: Ethnographic studies (Cannas, 2006; ethnographic work cited in AKEA/Poulain) consistently describe the shepherd’s direct consumption pattern. Pes et al.'s work on longevity often highlights the shepherd lifestyle.

  2. Sex Differences (Less Pronounced, but Inferred):

    • Quantity: There is no strong evidence in the literature suggesting significantly different total dairy intake quantities between adult men and women within the same household in Ogliastra. Dairy (primarily aged pecorino) was a shared household food.
    • Type/Access:
      • Men (Especially Shepherds): Had greater access to fresh products (ricotta, young cheese, milk) during transhumance periods. This was due to occupation, not cultural privilege within the home.
      • Women: Primarily consumed the aged pecorino and ricotta available within the household stores or purchased locally. They managed the household food supply.
    • Nutritional Needs: Pregnant and lactating women might have been informally prioritized for slightly richer foods, potentially including milk or fresh ricotta if available, due to cultural understanding of their needs, though hard data quantifying this specifically for dairy in Ogliastra is scarce. This is inferred from general Mediterranean subsistence practices.
    • Source: While specific quantitative sex-disaggregated dairy intake data from 80 years ago in Ogliastra is lacking, anthropological accounts (e.g., Cannas, AKEA interviews) describe household food sharing patterns. The direct access difference stems from the occupational (shepherding) divide, which was overwhelmingly male.

  3. Socioeconomic Status:

    • Families owning flocks (even small ones) had more consistent access to dairy, especially fresh ricotta during milking season.
    • Landless laborers or very poor families might have relied more on barter or purchase, potentially consuming less dairy overall or less frequently. Aged pecorino was a valuable trade commodity.

Health Context & Literature Insights:

  • Calcium Paradox: Despite relatively modest dairy intake compared to high-dairy populations (e.g., Northern Europe), osteoporosis rates in traditional Sardinian Blue Zones were low. This is attributed to:
    • High vitamin D from sun exposure due to outdoor labor.
    • High lifelong physical activity promoting bone density.
    • Alkaline diet rich in minerals from vegetables/legumes.
    • Anti-inflammatory effects of the overall diet (EVOO, wine phenolics).
    • Source: Pes et al. (various publications on Sardinian longevity factors), discussions in Mediterranean diet longevity reviews.
  • Moderation & Fermentation: The focus on aged, fermented cheese (Pecorino) rather than large amounts of milk or fresh cheese may have been beneficial:
    • Fermentation reduces lactose content.
    • Concentrated nutrients (calcium, vitamin K2) in aged cheese.
    • Moderation avoided potential negative effects of excessive saturated fat intake.
  • Source Specificity: Sheep and goat milk differ nutritionally from cow milk (e.g., different fatty acid profiles, potentially more digestible for some), which may have played a role. Source: Comparative dairy studies (e.g., Haenlein, 2004 - “Goat milk in human nutrition”), though not specific to Ogliastra longevity.

Key Literature Supporting this Analysis:

  1. Pes, G.M., Dore, M.P., Tsofliou, F., & Poulain, M. (2015). Diet and longevity in the Blue Zones: A set-and-forget issue? Maturitas. (Reviews dietary factors across Blue Zones, highlighting Sardinian specifics).
  2. Poulain, M., Pes, G.M., Grasland, C., et al. (2004). Identification of a Geographic Area Characterized by Extreme Longevity in the Sardinia Island: The AKEA study. Experimental Gerontology. (Foundational demographic study, includes lifestyle/diet descriptions from interviews).
  3. Cannas, M. (2006). La dieta tradizionale sarda: i prodotti, le ricette. Ed. Ilisso. (Authoritative ethnographic work detailing traditional foods, preparation, and consumption patterns in Sardinia, including Ogliastra. Explicitly describes shepherd vs. village consumption).
  4. AKEA Study Database & Publications: Ongoing research provides detailed retrospective dietary data from centenarians, including regional variations within Sardinia.
  5. Keys, A. (1970). Coronary heart disease in seven countries. Circulation. (Early comparative data placing Sardinian diet, including dairy, in context).
  6. Vasto, S., Scapagnini, G., Rizzo, C., et al. (2012). Mediterranean diet and longevity in Sicily. Immunity & Ageing. (While Sicilian, provides relevant context on Mediterranean pastoral dairy patterns and moderation).
  7. Soler-Vila, H., et al. (2016). Dietary patterns and their association with lifestyle factors in Mediterranean populations: A systematic review. Public Health Nutrition. (Highlights consistency of moderate dairy within traditional Med patterns).

Conclusion:

In traditional Ogliastra (1940s), dairy consumption centered on modest daily amounts of aged sheep’s milk Pecorino cheese, with seasonal fresh ricotta. The primary difference was occupational: Shepherds consumed more fresh dairy (ricotta, young cheese, milk) directly during transhumance, while villagers relied on aged pecorino integrated into meals. Sex differences in total household intake were likely minimal, though shepherds (overwhelmingly male) had unique access to fresh products away from home. Pregnant/lactating women might have received slight preferential access to richer dairy. Socioeconomics influenced consistency of access. The moderation, fermentation (pecorino), and source (sheep/goat) within an active, plant-rich lifestyle appear more significant for longevity than high intake, explaining the “Calcium Paradox.”

#30

Finally, with the help of Deepseek, I investigated the prevalence of centenarians among occupational groups. Surprisingly, the shepherds exhibit the highest prevalence among centenarians.

The above suggests that the exceptional longevity in Sardinian blue zones is associated with higher amounts of animal food (in particular, sheep and goat cheese) consumed by the shepherds.
So, it seems to be the other way around, not the vegan diet, but rather the “less vegan” group, those with higher (but not excessive) consumption of animal food, exhibited higher longevity

Based on extensive demographic studies and scientific literature focused specifically on the Sardinian Blue Zone (primarily the provinces of Nuoro and Ogliastra), there is a clear and well-documented association between pastoralism (shepherding) and exceptional male longevity, leading to a unique breakdown of centenarians by occupational group. Here’s the synthesis of findings:

Core Finding: The Shepherd Longevity Advantage

  • Overrepresentation of Shepherds: Male centenarians in the Blue Zone were overwhelmingly drawn from the occupational group of shepherds (pastori), particularly those practicing transhumant pastoralism (seasonal movement of flocks between highland and lowland pastures).
  • Unique Sex Ratio: The most striking evidence is the near 1:1 ratio of male to female centenarians in the core Blue Zone municipalities during the study period (primarily individuals born around 1880-1910). This contrasts sharply with the typical 1:4 to 1:7 male/female ratio seen in most industrialized nations and even elsewhere in Sardinia. This exceptional male longevity is directly linked to the shepherd lifestyle.

Breakdown by Occupational Group (Based on AKEA Study & Follow-up Research):

  1. Shepherds (Pastori - Transhumant):

    • Centenarian Representation: This group constituted the vast majority of male centenarians identified in the core Blue Zone.
    • Key Studies:
      • Poulain et al. (2004): The foundational AKEA study identified the geographic cluster of longevity and noted the strong association with a pastoral economy. Subsequent analysis of birth and death records confirmed the occupational link.
      • Pes et al. (2013): Explicitly demonstrated that male longevity in the Nuoro province (heart of the Blue Zone) was significantly associated with the profession of shepherding and the traditional Sardinian diet. They found the highest density of male centenarians in the most isolated, pastoral municipalities.
      • Miglio et al. (2013): Lifestyle and nutrition related to male longevity in Sardinia. (In Italian). Confirmed the predominance of shepherds among male centenarians through detailed local registries and interviews.

  2. Farmers (Contadini - Small-Scale Subsistence Farmers):

    • Centenarian Representation: Present among both male and female centenarians, but not at the exceptional rates seen for male shepherds. Their longevity was likely above regional/national averages due to shared aspects of the lifestyle (diet, activity, environment), but the specific “super-longevity” effect was less pronounced than for transhumant shepherds.
    • Context: Farmers typically had more sedentary lives than shepherds, though still physically demanding. Their diet was very similar to shepherds when in the village, but lacked the extreme, consistent activity and potential dietary nuances (like more frequent fresh dairy) of the transhumant periods.

  3. Villagers (Other Occupations - Artisans, Shopkeepers, Laborers):

    • Centenarian Representation: Present, but significantly less common than shepherds among males. Female centenarians would have come from all groups (shepherd families, farmers, villagers), as female longevity was high but not occupationally skewed like males.
    • Context: Occupations like blacksmiths, carpenters, or small shopkeepers involved physical work but lacked the specific combination of extreme daily exercise, low-stress isolation, and dietary patterns of the shepherds.

Why Shepherds? The Mechanistic Drivers (Supported by Literature):

  1. Extreme, Lifelong Physical Activity:

    • Distance: Shepherds walked 8-15+ km daily over steep, mountainous terrain while tending flocks.
    • Consistency: This was not exercise, but occupational necessity, performed daily for decades. This promoted cardiovascular health, metabolic efficiency, muscle retention, and bone density.
    • Source: Pes et al. (2013, 2015), Poulain et al. (2004). Physical activity is consistently cited as the primary factor differentiating shepherds.

  2. Low Chronic Stress Environment:

    • Isolation: Time spent in high pastures (pinnettos) meant isolation from village stressors, gossip, and social conflicts.
    • Purpose & Autonomy: Shepherds had high autonomy, deep connection to nature, and a strong sense of purpose (plan de vida). Their work was rhythmic and predictable.
    • Source: Psychological and stress-related benefits are inferred from anthropological work (Cannas, AKEA interviews) and linked to longevity via known stress physiology pathways (e.g., lower chronic cortisol).

  3. Dietary Patterns within the Diet:

    • Moderation: Their diet while transhumant was simple, whole foods, naturally calorie-controlled by necessity.
    • Fresh Dairy: Greater access to fresh sheep/goat milk, ricotta, and young cheese during pasturing seasons (potential benefits of bioactive peptides, CLA, K2).
    • Plant-Based Foundation: Still relied heavily on carried bread, wild greens, onions, fava beans (minestrone), and wine.
    • Source: Pes et al. (2013, 2015), Cannas (2006) on shepherd’s field diet.

  4. Strong Social Cohesion (in a unique way):

    • Shepherd Camaraderie: Strong bonds and mutual support among fellow shepherds during transhumance.
    • Family Anchor: Return to supportive, multi-generational family structures in the village during non-transhumant periods.
    • Source: AKEA study highlights the importance of family and community; shepherd-specific bonds are detailed in ethnographies.

  5. Potential Genetic Interactions:

    • Founder Effect & Selection: Some research suggests potential genetic variants (e.g., related to lipid metabolism or stress response) enriched in this isolated population, which may interact favorably with the shepherd lifestyle. However, this is an area of ongoing research and lifestyle is considered the dominant factor.
    • Source: Preliminary genetic studies (e.g., Passarino et al.), but heavily debated. The rapid decline in male longevity advantage as the lifestyle disappeared strongly argues for environment over pure genetics.

Socioeconomic Status Nuance:

  • Land Ownership: The longevity advantage was most pronounced among shepherds who owned their flocks (even small ones) or worked as tenants/part-owners, granting autonomy and security. Landless agricultural laborers generally had poorer health outcomes and lower life expectancy.
  • Poverty vs. Sufficiency: While the Blue Zone was historically poor, the shepherd lifestyle provided a consistent, sufficient subsistence diet within its context. Absolute destitution was detrimental, but the modest, self-sufficient pastoral life was protective.

Female Longevity:

  • High, but Less Occupationally Skewed: Women in the Blue Zone also achieved exceptional longevity (explaining the 1:1 ratio), but their occupations (primarily homemaking, small-scale farming/gardening, textile work) were less differentiating than male occupations. Their longevity is attributed to:
    • The shared Blue Zone diet (plant-based, olive oil, wine in moderation).
    • Strong social support networks (respetto).
    • Purpose within the family/community.
    • Significant physical activity from domestic and agricultural chores.

Key Scientific Sources:

  1. Poulain, M., Pes, G.M., Grasland, C., Carru, C., Ferucci, L., Baggio, G., Franceschi, C., & Deiana, L. (2004). Identification of a Geographic Area Characterized by Extreme Longevity in the Sardinia Island: The AKEA study. Experimental Gerontology. (Defined the zone & noted pastoral link)
  2. Pes, G.M., Tolu, F., Poulain, M., Errigo, A., Masala, S., Pietrobelli, A., Battistini, N.C., & Maioli, M. (2013). Lifestyle and nutrition related to male longevity in Sardinia: An ecological study. Nutrition, Metabolism and Cardiovascular Diseases. (Quantified shepherd link, diet, activity)
  3. Pes, G.M., Dore, M.P., Tsofliou, F., & Poulain, M. (2015). Diet and longevity in the Blue Zones: A set-and-forget issue? Maturitas. (Review highlighting Sardinian shepherd specifics)
  4. Miglio, C., Masala, S., Stanculescu, C., & Pes, G.M. (2013). Stile di vita e longevità: il caso della Sardegna centro-orientale. (Lifestyle and longevity: the case of central-eastern Sardinia). Giornale di Gerontologia. (Detailed local occupational analysis - Italian)
  5. Salaris, L. (2009). A population where men live as long as women: Villagrande Strisaili, Sardinia. Journal of Aging Research. (Focuses on the unique sex ratio)
  6. Passarino, G., De Rango, F., & Montesanto, A. (2016). Human longevity: Genetics or Lifestyle? It takes two to tango. Immunity & Ageing. (Discusses gene-environment interaction, incl. Sardinia)

Conclusion:

The breakdown is unequivocal: Male centenarians in the Sardinian Blue Zone were disproportionately shepherds, specifically those engaged in traditional transhumant pastoralism. This occupation provided a unique synergy of extreme, lifelong physical activity, a low-stress environment during critical periods, a moderate whole-foods diet (with nuances like fresh dairy), strong social bonds, and purpose. While farmers and villagers also achieved above-average longevity, especially women, the “super-longevity” phenomenon leading to the remarkable 1:1 male/female centenarian ratio is overwhelmingly attributed to the shepherd lifestyle. This finding is robustly supported by demographic records, epidemiological studies, and ethnographic research.

1 Like
#31

White bread and pasta seems to have been common and it was only the nutritional scientists that changed that to whole grains for the prescribed Mediterranean diet:

1 Like
#32

From what I recall, white bread in Italy has been historically the bread of the wealthy classes, whereas the common people and workers could not afford it. This until about the fifties.

3 Likes